Friday, 14 December 2007

Personality: the big 5

Having recently had my first child, Isabel, make an appearance on the scene, I've got interested in personality and how it's formed.

The "big five" personality traits most commonly used are:
- extraversion (response to positive stimuli)
- neuroticism (reponse to negative stimuli)
- conscientiousness (impulse control)
- agreeableness (acting on empathy)
- openness (breadth of activation)

In terms of where they come from, the mainstream of research indicates:
- 40-50% of the variation is set via inheritance
- of the remaining 50-60% of variance, some will be due to random brain wiring and some to random environmental influences
- parental influence has no effect

The last point, in particular, is somewhat counter-intuitive. There's a natural association in most people's minds between types of family atmosphere and the character of the adults who result from growing up in it. But as far as people can tell from studies designed to tease out the effects of genes vs environment (twin studies, adoption studies, etc), the effect is from inherited tendency rather than how a child is bought up. Extraverted parents have extraverted children because the child has a natural tendedncy, not because the child is growing up in an extraverted household. And so on.

Does this make any difference to how one should act as a parent? Perhaps. One might draw the conclusion that you should pay attention to how your child seems to be as an individual, rather than viewing it as a blank template on which behaviour must be imposed and molded.

In terms of what one might wish for one's child, most of the traits are pretty neutral. What you want is for people to find a path that is in sympathy with their personality.

For example - personally, I'm very high on agreeableness and openness, high on extraversion and conscientiousness, and average on neuroticism. This means I'm great on stuff involving solving ill-defined problems that need wide co-operation across a number of people to tackle, and where attention to detail is important. I'm crap on stuff involving carrying out someone else's plan, where it's going to cause a lot of people pain, and lots of things will go wrong in the execution that I can't do anything to prevent.

So my current job troubleshooting analytics-related problems across derivatives trading areas is a good match. But maybe I should put off joining the army for a while longer.

And as for Isabel? Bearing in mind she's only 4 months old so far, it's hard to tell. I do have one wish: I hope that she's not at the top end in neuroticism, as by definition it's a lot harder to be happy if you are. And for myself, I hope I can help her to get the most out of life, however she turns out.

No comments: